Why we made dear vanity

I used to build apps that changed people's faces

For ten years, I built camera apps and photo apps for smartphones. Most of them had a beauty filter that slimmed the face and made the eyes bigger. People loved it, and I never questioned it. When I started a new selfie app, I assumed the same. A clean selfie app with no ads, and face retouching, of course.

Then one day, I was taking a photo of someone I love, and my finger stopped over the shutter. Out of habit, I had opened a beauty camera, and the face on the screen looked a little unfamiliar. What I wanted to keep was the face right in front of me. I had grown so used to those cameras that I was about to change the face of someone I love without a second thought. That embarrassed me.

Good selfies happen for a reason

From that day, I asked a different question. Instead of "how do I fix this face?", I asked "when do people feel they look good?"

The answer was close by. Mirror selfies, elevator selfies, bathroom selfies. People tend to love how they look in these. When you photograph your reflection, the camera is effectively looking at you from behind the mirror, much farther away than your arm can reach.*

A typical selfie is taken about 30 cm, or a foot, from the face. That close, the nose looks bigger because it's nearest the lens, while the ears and the outline of the face look smaller. One study found that at that distance, the nose looks about 30% wider than in a photo taken from farther away.1

FACE ≈30 cm SELFIE ≈1.5 m A FRIEND
At arm's length the nose sits much closer to the lens than the ears do. From a friend's distance, that difference almost disappears.

So the stranger in your selfies was never your face. You were just too close.

The photo you can't post without a filter

Some researchers call it "Snapchat dysmorphia": getting so used to your filtered face that your real one starts to feel wrong.2 I don't think that's anyone's fault. Wanting to look good is natural. But if the only way to get there is changing your face, we all drift a little further from our own.

What we won't change, and what we'll care for

So dear vanity has one rule. It never touches the shape of your eyes, nose or jaw. It only undoes the distortion that comes from being too close, so the photo looks like a friend took it from a step away.

We do refine lighting and skin. Clearing a blemish or smoothing skin texture feels closer to makeup to me. It's caring for your face, not changing it.

AI can now make a perfect face in seconds. In a world like that, I believe photos that capture a face as it really is will only become more precious. I hope that the next time you look at a selfie, you won't go looking for things to fix. I hope you'll just smile and think, "I look good."

Dear Vanity, Wanting to look good is only natural. We'll keep that wish, and your face, just as they are. The people behind dear vanity, Rytos

* In a mirror selfie, light travels from your face to the mirror and back to the camera, so it's roughly like being photographed from twice the distance to the mirror.

1. Ward B, Ward M, Fried O, Paskhover B. "Nasal Distortion in Short-Distance Photographs: The Selfie Effect." JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery 2018;20(4):333–335. doi:10.1001/jamafacial.2018.0009

2. Rajanala S, Maymone MBC, Vashi NA. "Selfies—Living in the Era of Filtered Photographs." JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery 2018;20(6):443–444. doi:10.1001/jamafacial.2018.0486